Executive counteroffer: how to avoid losing your chosen hire

A counteroffer is the proposal a professional's current employer makes to keep them after they announce they are leaving for another company: a higher salary, a bigger title or other improved terms. When a company hires an executive, the counteroffer usually comes at the worst moment for the hiring company, after the candidate has accepted the offer and is handing in their resignation. The hiring company reduces that risk when it understands from the start why the executive wants to move, makes an offer that answers those reasons and stays in touch until the first day.

What is a counteroffer

A counteroffer is an improvement in terms that a current employer puts to a professional after they say they have an offer from another company or intend to resign. Its purpose is to make the professional stay. It can include a pay rise, a new title, more responsibility, a retention bonus or changes to how the person works.

For an executive, a counteroffer has three distinctive features:

  • It comes late in the process. It usually appears once the executive has accepted another offer and announces their departure, not before.
  • It goes beyond salary. An executive may be offered a seat on the management committee, an equity stake or a long-term incentive.
  • It affects two companies. The current employer tries to keep a key person, and the hiring company may lose a search that has taken months.

Why a company makes a counteroffer to an executive

A company makes a counteroffer to an executive because losing them costs more than keeping them, at least in the short term. An executive's departure leaves a function without leadership, forces the company to open a search and puts at risk projects, teams and client relationships that depend on that person.

A counteroffer is also often a reaction to surprise. Many companies only find out what an executive values, or what they are missing, when the executive announces they are leaving. At that point the counteroffer tries to fix in days a situation that has been building for months.

Why an executive accepts or rejects a counteroffer

An executive accepts a counteroffer when the new proposal solves whatever made them look elsewhere, and rejects it when the underlying reasons are still there. The decision depends less on the figure than on the original question: why the executive was willing to change companies.

Reasons to accept a counteroffer

An executive tends to accept a counteroffer for one of these reasons:

  • The reason for leaving was mainly financial and the counteroffer matches or beats the new offer.
  • The move feels daunting. Leaving a familiar environment, a team they built and an internal reputation has a personal cost that weighs more at the end of the process than at the start.
  • The current employer finally recognises their role with a title or responsibilities the executive had been waiting for.
  • The hiring company has not settled their doubts about the project, the team or the fit with the owners.

Reasons to reject a counteroffer

An executive tends to reject a counteroffer when the decision to leave had nothing to do with money:

  • No project or no room to grow. A pay rise does not change the strategy or the ceiling of the role.
  • Disagreements with management or the owners. The relationship that made them look elsewhere is the same after the counteroffer.
  • Distrust. If the company only improves terms when the executive threatens to leave, the executive may read it as a sign of how they are valued.
  • Commitment to the new company. An executive who has met the team, negotiated their move and given their word usually prefers to keep it.

Accepting a counteroffer or moving on: the differences

Accepting a counteroffer and moving to a new company solve different problems. Staying on better terms protects what is familiar; moving opens a new project with more uncertainty. The table sums up what an executive weighs, and what the hiring company should know the candidate is comparing.

Attribute Accept the counteroffer Move to the new company
Pay Immediate rise, negotiated under pressure As agreed in the offer, negotiated calmly
Project The same one, perhaps with more responsibility New, with the challenge that prompted the move
Relationship with management The same as before the announcement To be built from scratch
Main risk The reasons for leaving come back The cultural fit does not work
Internal image May be seen as someone who nearly left No history at the company
Relationship with the hiring company An accepted commitment is broken The commitment is kept

Neither column is better in the abstract. The right decision depends on whether the reasons that made the executive look elsewhere can be solved from within.

Questions to ask before deciding on a counteroffer

An executive who receives a counteroffer can decide more clearly by asking these questions before answering:

  1. Why did I start listening to other offers? Does the counteroffer solve that reason or only the pay?
  2. Was the improvement available before I announced I was leaving? If not, what does that say about how decisions are made here?
  3. Does anything change in my relationship with management or the owners?
  4. What project will I have in 12 months' time at each of the two companies?
  5. Have I given my word to the new company? What would breaking it cost my reputation?

The hiring company can ask the candidate the same questions during the process, long before any counteroffer arrives. The answers show whether the decision to move is firm.

Executive notice period in Spain: when the counteroffer comes

The notice period is the time an executive must stay with their employer after resigning, and it is when almost every counteroffer is negotiated. For senior management staff in Spain, Royal Decree 1382/1985 sets a minimum notice period of three months, which can be extended to six if agreed in writing.

Article 10.1 of Royal Decree 1382/1985, which governs the special employment relationship of senior management in Spain, provides that the contract ends at the senior executive's will with a minimum notice period of three months. That period can be extended to six months if set out in writing in open-ended contracts or contracts lasting more than five years. Under article 10.2, if the senior executive does not serve the notice, the employer is entitled to compensation equal to the salary for the period not served.

Many executives and managers in Spain do not have a senior management contract but an ordinary employment relationship. For them, article 49.1.d of the Workers' Statute (Estatuto de los Trabajadores) provides that an employee who resigns must give the notice set by collective agreements or local custom. The exact period therefore depends on the contract and the applicable collective agreement, and it is worth reviewing with an employment lawyer.

For the hiring company, the practical consequence is clear: three months or more can pass between an executive accepting the offer and their first day. During that time, the executive is still at their current employer, which has the chance to make a counteroffer.

How the hiring company reduces counteroffer risk

The hiring company reduces counteroffer risk mainly before making the offer: by understanding why the executive wants to move and building a proposal that answers those reasons. After that, the risk falls by staying in touch during the notice period. An offer that competes only on pay is the easiest one to match.

During the search process

The hiring company reduces counteroffer risk during the search by checking the candidate's motivation early and checking it again before the offer. These are the most useful practices:

  • Ask why the candidate wants to move, and separate financial reasons from reasons to do with the project, leadership or culture.
  • Talk openly about counteroffers before the final offer: what the candidate would do if their employer improved their terms.
  • Present the project in detail, with access to the owners or the chief executive, so the candidate compares projects and not just figures.
  • Keep the process short. Every week of waiting gives the candidate more time to hesitate and their employer more time to react.

A well-run executive search works on these questions from the first conversation. Neuronix, an executive search firm with offices in Barcelona and Sant Cugat del Vallès, combines expert judgement with a reading of culture in every search: beyond the track record, it looks at how the person fits the company's culture and its current situation. An executive who moves for the project and the fit is harder to keep with a pay rise. The house view sums up the approach: success is not the hire itself but the leadership impact at 12 and 18 months. Among the results it publishes on its website, Neuronix puts retention during the first 18 months at +90 %.

Between accepting the offer and the start date

Between accepting the offer and the first day, the hiring company reduces counteroffer risk by keeping the executive connected to the project throughout the notice period. A candidate who spends three months without hearing from the new company is left exposed to pressure from the current one.

Some ways to keep that connection:

  • Put the offer in writing and get it signed as soon as there is agreement, so the commitment is clear to both sides.
  • Introduce the executive to the team they will work with and to the key people in management.
  • Invite them to occasional meetings or events, without asking them to work while they are still with their current employer.
  • Prepare their arrival in advance and share the plan for their first months with them.

If the executive's current contract includes a non-compete clause or a longer agreed notice period, the hiring company should know about it before setting the start date and have it reviewed by an employment lawyer.